If someone makes a positive statement then yes the burden is on them to prove it e.g. "God exists". If someone a negative statement e.g. "God does not exist" then they do not have to prove it. The fact that there is no evidence that God does exist is sufficent enough to justify the logic "God does not exist". Its like for example someone saying " I don't believe in the Tessopglory monster of Antartica - he doesn't then have to prove that it doesn't exist - the fact that there is no evidence to suggest its existence is enough.
Do you understand anything of what I've just wrote?
Fair enough so then you're not actually participating in this debate then... you're just a spectator? The question was 'does God exist'. What do you claim? Yes or no? If you're not going to commit to either then fair enough but that's what this debate is about.
Fair enough. I'm not a physicist so I can't really argue with you on it. It is just quite difficult to believe that we can be absolutely sure that matter comes into existence without any cause. It would seem to me impossible to prove that there is no cause. I would have thought that the opinion would have been that we just don't know the cause of why matter comes into existence. But again i really don't know.
I'm sorry I don't understand. The point in doing what?
My point was that a rabbit that magically appears in the magicians could be said to appear out of no where, therefore it may seem like particles appear out of the no where but in reality there is some sort of cause. The same could debunk the theory you're talking about by saying there is a cause and we just don't know it yet.
To Dana and anyone else who says that atheists have to prove that God doesn't exist:
Its up to theists to prove that God exists not atheists to prove it doesn't. If I show you a rock in the middle of the USA and say "this keeps away tigers, prove to me it doesn't". I'm going to look like an idiot, which is what you look like everytime you say "prove that God doesn't exist.".
Particles are like rabbits then? When the magician pulls it out of the hat, I guess this proves that rabbits are usually born from their mothers but sometimes they just appear in magician's hats out of no where.
...Or maybe not. Maybe the magician is doing something we don't understand ust like the particles in the casimir effect ;)
You're playing with words. "Is what people say about God true?" is the same question as "Does God exist?". When people ask that question they're not talking about whether God exists as a concept. They're talking about whether he exists as a God: the creator and ruler of the universe and source of all moral authority.