Return to CreateDebate.comacrd • Join this debate community

A Civil Religious Debate


Debate Info

1
0
Yes No
Debate Score:1
Arguments:1
Total Votes:1
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (1)

Debate Creator

Pandeist(5) pic



Itiagwigawam

IF there is a God who is (1) wise and (2) good and (3) merciful, then those who try to do good will not be punished for their beliefs alone -- no matter what they do or do not believe.

Yes

Side Score: 1
VS.

No

Side Score: 0
1 point

A God who is wise in the sense of God-level wisdom would be wise enough to know what were the personal limitations which each and every person strove to overcome in life, what were their reasons for adopting and adhering to whatever belief system, and were those reasons defensible given their specific circumstances. Such an enquiry would be beyond mere human evaluators, and would require the fallback to deontological shortcuts, propositions of unbending systems of rules the violation of which reflexively resulted in an assigned punishment. The premise that justice requires bureaucratic slavishness to a small and certain set of rules, with a small and certain set of exceptions, is a product of limitedness. For an unlimited being -- or even one whose limitations still allow it sufficient capacity to consider every facet which might reasonably influence a determination of a 'just' outcome, the enquiry as to what is just becomes one with the enquiry as to what is merciful. Every possible basis for bestowal of mercy becomes known and apparent.

Side: yes
No arguments found. Add one!